Li, Rita Yi Man, Li, Herru Ching Yu; Mak, Cho Kei; Tang, Tang, Beiqi (2016) Sustainable smart home 
and  home  automation:  big  data  analytics  approach,  International  Journal  of  Smart  Home,  10(8), 
177-187 
Sustainable smart home and home automation:   
big data analytics approach 
 
Rita Yi Man Li1; Herru Ching Yu Li2; Cho Kei Mak1; Tony Beiqi Tang1 
Sustainable Real Estate Research Center, Hong Kong Shue Yan University 
School of Computer Science, University of St Andrews / Sustainable Real Estate 
Research Center, Hong Kong Shue Yan University   
 
Abstract 
Popularity  of  information  technology  not  only  changes  the  façade  of  data  management,  but 
powers smart home and city movement. Despite there are many different types of smart home 
technologies, lots of them share similar goal of sustainable development. Heaps of these tools 
improve energy generation or save energy and reduce water wastage. Beyond doubt, some of 
them  achieve  the  win-win-win  co-development  in  environment,  social  and  economics.  In this 
paper,  we  firstly  discuss  three  generations  of  smart  home:  (1)  Bluetooth  and  Zigbee  enables 
smart  technologies,  (2)  smart  home  with  artificial  intelligence  and  (3)  smart  home  robot 
which  can  stroll  around  home.  We  then  adopt  big  data  analytics  method  to  study  the 
popularity  of  smart  home  and  home  automation  searches  in  Google  from  2004  to  2016. 
Finally,  we  search  for  the  latest  smart  home  technologies  that  can  achieve  the  goal  of 
sustainable  development.  The  results  show  that  nations  which  are  keen  on  smart  home  and 
home automation devices do not only restrict on the richest countries in the World. All the top 
three  cities  with  the  largest  number  of  Google  searches  in  home  automation  over  the  past 
decade  come  from  India.  They  are  famous  information  technology  (IT)  hubs  with  many  IT 
personnel. We  speculate that  interests  in  smart  home  /  home  automation  are  correlated  with 
residents’  computer  literacy  rather  than  economic  wealthiness.  Besides,  the  research  shows 
that many of the sustainable home technologies mainly focus on energy saving. Water saving 
smart  home  devices  only  happen  once  in  a  blue  moon.  That  may  be  reflected  in  the  relative 
high costs in using electricity as compared to water in many cities around the World. In short, 
the research offers academic, practical and policy contribution. 
 
Keywords: sustainable development, computer aided technologies, facilities, smart homes 
 
1.  Introduction 
In  recent  decades,  new  electrical  appliances  increase  the  use  of  electricity.  Electricity  grids 
expand and more fuels are consumed. At the same time, shrinking water resources Worldwide 
and  the  rising  costs  of  water  prompts  residential  occupants to  adopt  conservation  tactics  (1). 
Hence,  politicians  put  forward  new  policies;  environmentalists  suggest  viable  solutions  and 
researchers  explore  new  technologies  to  reduce  the  use  of  water  and  electricity  resources. 
 
1 
 Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=2834497 
Li, Rita Yi Man, Li, Herru Ching Yu; Mak, Cho Kei; Tang, Tang, Beiqi (2016) Sustainable smart home 
and  home  automation:  big  data  analytics  approach,  International  Journal  of  Smart  Home,  10(8), 
177-187 
Modern residents call for modern residential facilities to enhance social well-being but at the 
same  time  reduce  costs.  Beyond  doubt,  smart  home  apparatus  is  born  at  the  right  time  and 
place to provide sustainable solutions for home owners.   
 
Smart  home  is  often  discussed  together  with  the  idea  of  home  automation.  It  distributes 
commands and information via wireless network to electrical appliances, information gadgets 
and  other  internet-based  applications  via  an  ubiquitous  home  network  (1).  Güneş  and  Akdaş 
(2) concede that home automation systems allow users to control security, lighting, ventilation 
and  temperature.  Balasubramanian  and  Cellatoglu  (3)  suggests  that  home  automation  saves 
electricity and protects occupants from intruders. Reaz (4) finds that a friendly user interface 
enhances home automation  efficiency. Benmansour, Bouchachia (5) believes that we  need to 
consider the number and types of occupants in smart home. Collotta and Pau (6) contend that 
application  of  Bluetooth  Low  to  manage  energy  enhances  consumers  comfort  via  peak  load 
energy demand reduction and allows more appliances to operate at the same time.   
 
2.  Three generations of smart home technologies 
In recent years, various computational methods have been proposed for the advancement and 
development  of  sophisticated  control  systems  of  Smart  Home  Environment  (7).  Smart 
air-conditioners,  security  devices,  mobile  phones  and  home  theatres  put  theoretical  smart 
home into practice (8). A myriad of them utilize the technology of artificial intelligence (AI), 
multi-agent systems and automation control.   
 
2.1  The  first  generation  of  smart  home:  wireless  technology  and  proxy  server  home 
automation approach   
The first generation smart home devices are used to monitor occupants’ activities and operate 
electrical  devices  in  a  predefined  pattern.  The  Advanced  Metering  Infra-structure,  for 
example,  sends  time-varying  electricity  price  messages  to  smart  meters  in  residents’  houses. 
Smart meters issue instructions to adjust power usage (8). Besides, smart home also provides 
support  for  paralyzed  patient  (9).  To  develop  and  improve  home  services,  researchers  shed 
light  on  home  automation  by  introducing  Bluetooth  home  automation  system  which  connect 
electrical  home  devices  to  one  Bluetooth  sub-controller.  The  system  lowers  the  needs  of 
electrical  wires  and  intrusive  electrical  installation  via  wireless  technology.  Nevertheless, 
sharing of one single Bluetooth between large number of devices often lead to an access delay, 
ZigBee-based home automation network is therefore introduced. The network requires a local 
proxy server to enable communication between electrical appliances and the internet. Another 
possible solution to solve the abovementioned problem  may involve Internet of Things (IoT) 
which  gears  an  all-IP  solution  based  on  IPv6  Routing  over  Low  Power  and  Lossy  Network 
(RoLL) (10). 
 
2 
 Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=2834497 
Li, Rita Yi Man, Li, Herru Ching Yu; Mak, Cho Kei; Tang, Tang, Beiqi (2016) Sustainable smart home 
and  home  automation:  big  data  analytics  approach,  International  Journal  of  Smart  Home,  10(8), 
177-187 
 
Apart  from  ivory  research,  the  private  sector  also  realizes  the  potential  of  smart  home  and 
introduces  heaps  of  relevant  new  technologies  and  products.  For  example,  Samsung 
introduces  a  SmartThings  hub  which  can  monitor  and  control  electrical  devices  when  users 
are away from their place via android and Apple iPhones (11). NuBryte introduces Touchpoint 
All-in-One Smart Home Console. It can light switch with Touchpoint. It can control Nybryte 
App  by  using  different  Android  and  iPhone.  It  also  has  different  light  modes  including 
bedtime  mode,  dimming  mode.  NuBryte  also  has  wide-angle  camera  which  can  let  other 
mobile phones to receive immediate alert when there are intruders. It can also update weather 
information, calendar, events, energy monitoring (12). 
 
Smart devices not only include products which can control other smart products but also send 
reminder  to  users.  Quirky  Egg  Minder  Wink  App  Enabled  Smart  Egg  Tray  notifies  users 
about the number of eggs in fridges and whether the eggs turn bad. The egg tray also has LED 
lights to distinguish which eggs are the oldest (13). 
 
2.2  The  second  generation  of  smart  home:  artificial  intelligence  controls  electrical 
devices 
It has evolved to the notion of Smart Home Environments (SHE). SHE exhibits various forms 
of  “artificial  intelligence”  by  improving  traditional  home  automation  systems  with  new 
“smart functions”. It increases comfortableness, lowers operation costs and enhances security. 
A myriads of computational methods are proposed for the design as well as the sophisticated 
Control  Systems  development  for  SHE  with  the  help  from  automation,  artificial  intelligence 
(AI) and multi-agent systems (14). 
 
Prior  2015,  even  though  it  is  widely  believed  that  there  is  close  relationship  between  smart 
home and artificial intelligence, technology as such mainly operates in laboratory rather than 
everyday use at home (15). One of the examples is the iSpace in the University of Essex. It is 
fitted  with  intelligent  devices  to  detect  and  learn  from  users’  behaviors  an  provides 
suggestions  according  to  users’  needs.  These  devices  can  communicate  with  each  other, 
coordinate actions and allow remote access via Internet and GSM (16).   
In  2014,  Amazon  Echo  was  introduced  by  the  internet  bookstore  giant-Amazon.  It  is  a 
sophisticated product unlike other smart home devices only accepts users’ instructions, it can 
listen  users’  questions  and  answer  them.  It  reports  information  about  traffic  and  weather, 
provides  updates  about  news,  sport  scores  and  users’  schedule.  It  also  controls  lights, 
thermostats  and  switches.  Moreover,  it  will  become  smarter  as  users  interact  with  it  and  it 
processes the ability to learn (17). 
 
 
 
3 
Li, Rita Yi Man, Li, Herru Ching Yu; Mak, Cho Kei; Tang, Tang, Beiqi (2016) Sustainable smart home 
and  home  automation:  big  data  analytics  approach,  International  Journal  of  Smart  Home,  10(8), 
177-187 
2.3  Third  generation  of  smart  home:  robot  bubby  “who”  can  interacts  with  human 
beings 
Integration  of  service  robots  with  smart  home  system  is  the  current  trend  (18).  Affordable 
robots  are  equipped  with  artificial  intelligence  and  can  respond  to  human’s  needs  via  voice 
recognition.  For  example,  Zenbo  connects  to  smart  home  devices,  moves  freely  and 
independently  around  home,  sees  things  via  its  camera,  makes  video  calls,  recognizes  faces, 
takes photos and videos. Robots as such not only control smart things but can also be viewed 
as a buddy “who” can interact with human (19). 
Robot Rovio, a mobile robot equipped with a webcam, a microphone and loudspeakers, is one 
of  the  symbols  of  the  revolution  of  the  integration.  The  middleware  approach  that  has  been 
chosen to integrate the Rovio in the smart home is UPnP, which has already been used for this 
purpose  in  other  works.  Rovio  can  connect  with  other  UPnP  devices  such  as  smart  home 
systems or other service robots such as Roomba. Integration of Rovio in a UPnP environment 
shows how  easily service robots can be integrated in smart home and develop new advanced 
services that illustrate the benefits of interoperability in the smart home (18). 
No matter which generations of smart home, they improve people’s quality of life. In addition, 
some experts thought that smart home system could help disabled people to have a better and 
convenient  life.  Costa,  Carballa  (20)  realize  that  people,  especially  disabled  ones’  lives 
become more convenient in presence of home automation.   
 
3.  Research method previously used in smart home research 
Ethnographic  approach,  surveys  and  interviews  are  adopted  in  smart  home  research  (21). 
Fieldwork  study  with  contextual  interviews  at  interviewees’  homes  include  role-play, 
storytelling  and  artifact  walkthrough  activities  (22).  Other  novel  research  methods  for  smart 
home are recorded in the following Table.   
 
4 
Li,  Rita  Yi  Man,  Li,  Herru  Ching  Yu;  Mak,  Cho  Kei; Tang,  Tang,  Beiqi  (2016)  Sustainable  smart home  and home  automation:  big  data  analytics  approach,  International 
Journal of Smart Home, 10(8), 177-187 
 
Research approach 
Diary 
 
Provide  diaries  to  participants  to  record  their  experiences  and 
viewpoints when they use the system. 
Photographic study 
Request the smart home users to take photos of their own home. 
 
 
Results / merits of this research method 
 
 
 
 
Participants  keep  records  of  their  interactions  with  the 
system.   
It  successfully  engages  participants  in  the  process  of 
evaluation. 
 
It  provides  understanding  on  how  Smart  home  technologies 
References 
(21) 
(21) 
(21) 
Participants were given mission packs to finish tasks at homes. 
are  used  and  identify  the  roles  of  technology  in  people’s 
Focus group 
everyday lives in the future.   
 
 
 
 
 
Focus  groups  allow  research  participants  to  discuss  their  needs  and 
  Data collected in these booklets can provide a wide range of 
viewpoints after using smart home system. 
variety of information from the households for researchers at 
Participant  packs  are  planned  and  disseminated  for  the  Equipment 
each home visit.   
Management in home trial. 
 
The booklet records the interactions between researchers and 
They  used  resource  packs  to  keep  their  diaries  of  experiences, 
participants instantaneously. 
records of interaction and photos for the trial.   
Participants  are  given  A5  spiral  bound  record  books,  Post-it  note 
pads,  emotion  stickers  and  a  camera  to  record  their  ideas,  opinions 
and state of mind. 
Econometric forecasting approach 
 
 
 
5 
Li,  Rita  Yi  Man,  Li,  Herru  Ching  Yu;  Mak,  Cho  Kei; Tang,  Tang,  Beiqi  (2016)  Sustainable  smart home  and home  automation:  big  data  analytics  approach,  International 
Journal of Smart Home, 10(8), 177-187 
Research approach 
Results / merits of this research method 
References 
 
It forecasts temperature at home with sensors.   
 
The result shows that over three hours the accuracy is within 
(23) 
one  fifth  of  a  degree  Celsius  and  when  over  six  hours,  the 
accuracy will be within one half-degree Celsius based on the 
one or hours of history.   
Two schedule modelling 
 
It  studies  consumers’  incentives  in  power  consumption 
(24) 
It  analyses  the  maximum  power  consumption  in  smart  grid 
reduction. 
environment based on two scheduling models: online and offline.   
It adopts load model with dynamic pricing process 
 
 
 
Table 1 Research methods for smart home research
 
 
 
6 
Li, Rita Yi Man, Li, Herru Ching Yu; Mak, Cho Kei; Tang, Tang, Beiqi (2016) Sustainable smart home 
and  home  automation:  big  data  analytics  approach,  International  Journal  of  Smart  Home,  10(8), 
177-187 
3.1  Big data analytics 
In this research paper, we  adopt big data analytics  which can act as a proxy for studying the 
popularity  of smart home and  home automation in  different parts of the World from 2004 to 
2016.  In  this  section,  we  firstly  provide  a  brief  idea  on  data  analytics,  followed  by  big  data 
analytics. 
 
Data analytics  is the use of data collection and analysis to  optimize decision  making (25). It 
reviews  large  amount  of  raw  and  unorganized  data  to  identify  patterns  which  help 
organizations  or  decision  makers  to  have  a  better  understanding  of  behaviors.  It  is  a  useful 
tool  in  gaining  meaningful  insight  on  how  information,  sentiments,  as  well  as  opinion  are 
generated  (26).  Moreover,  analysis  identifies  and  determines  prevailing  trends  and  issues  in 
the  market.  Organizations  nowadays  always  use  data  analytics  to  infer  business  intelligence 
(BI)  from  social  media  content  for  making  the  decisions  and  formulate  various  business 
strategies  for  the  decision-makers.  Data  analytics  provides  opportunities  for  business 
intelligence creating a platform for the decision-makers to have a better understanding of the 
business performance. Business intelligence encompasses the processes and technologies used 
to obtain timely and valuable insights into business. However, Data analytics and BI are only 
the  aid  for  the  people  to  make  decisions,  they  should  process  their  analysis  based  on  their 
analytical  thinking  skills  after  getting  the  results  from  the  data  analysis  but  not  to  blindly 
make their decision according to the results from the data analysis. 
 
Nevertheless, there is challenge for the data analysis. One major challenge is data availability, 
including relevance and integrity of data analysis (27). For many managers and organizations, 
they  may not have the ability to capture data  such as computer skills and knowledge, or data 
may  contain  noise  and  asymmetric  information  problem  exists  (28).  Even  if  the  data  can  be 
readily  provided  and  the  decision-makers  are  granted  full  access,  they  have  to  consider  the 
integrity (27), completeness, ambiguity or quality of data.   
 
Big  Data  Analytics  (BDA)  applies  the  idea  of  data  analytics  but  that  aims  at  handling  huge 
volumes of data to identify trend, patterns and collect invaluable findings. Big Data Analysis 
often links with a mix of Oracle’s Big Data appliance and Cloudera’s Hadoop (29). 
 
4.  Research results 
Changes  in  interests  of  smart  home  and  home  automation  in  google  by  sheding  light  on 
keyword search from 2004 to 2016 is recorded in the following diagram. It shows that smart 
home has gained in interests over time but there is a decreasing interests in home automation. 
The largest number of searches country of smart home in Google search engine mainly comes 
from  Philippines,  the  US  and  Germany  where  the  largest  number  of  searches  of  the  cities 
 
7 
Li, Rita Yi Man, Li, Herru Ching Yu; Mak, Cho Kei; Tang, Tang, Beiqi (2016) Sustainable smart home 
and  home  automation:  big  data  analytics  approach,  International  Journal  of  Smart  Home,  10(8), 
177-187 
come from Pheonix (the US), Quezon City (Phillipines) and Austin (the US).   
 
With regards to home automation, the largest number of searches countries come from South 
Africa,  India  and  United  Arab  Emirates.  Cities  with  the  largets  number  of  keyword  search 
come from Bengaluru, Hyderabad and Chennai. All these three cities  locate in India and are 
famous for their information technology  development. Bengaluru is known as Indian Silicon 
Valley, Chennai emerges as another Indian Silicon Valley (30) and Hyderabad is the home of 
Google,  Apple,  Facebook  Microsoft  India.  The  results  to  certain  extend  overthrow  laymen 
viewpoints that home automation and smart home are fancy stuff which are only interested by 
rich  peoeple  and  countries  only.  The  results  show  that  there  is  closer  relationship  between 
computer knowledge and smart home technologies’ interests than economic development. 
Figure 1 A comparison between interests in home automation and smart home from 2004 to 
2016 in Google (red line indicates home automation wheras blue line represents smart home). 
 
Figure 2 Cities with the largest number of keyword search for smart home in Google (31). 
 
 
Figure 3 Cities with the largest number of search for smart home in Google (31). 
 
 
8