1
Multiple Antenna Aided NOMA in UAV
Networks: A Stochastic Geometry Approach
Tianwei Hou, Student Member, IEEE, Yuanwei Liu, Member, IEEE, Zhengyu
Song, Xin Sun, and Yue Chen, Senior Member, IEEE,
Abstract
This article investigates the multiple-input multiple-output (MIMO) non-orthogonal multiple access
(NOMA) assisted unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) networks. By utilizing a stochastic geometry model,
a new 3-Dimension UAV framework for providing wireless service to randomly roaming NOMA users
has been proposed. In an effort to evaluate the performance of the proposed framework, we derive
analytical expressions for the outage probability and the ergodic rate of MIMO-NOMA enhanced
UAV networks. We examine tractable upper bounds for the whole proposed framework, with deriving
asymptotic results for scenarios that transmit power of interference sources being proportional or being
fixed to the UAV. For obtaining more insights for the proposed framework, we investigate the diversity
order and high signal-to-noise (SNR) slope of MIMO-NOMA assisted UAV networks. Our results
confirm that: i) The outage probability of NOMA enhanced UAV networks is affected to a large extent
by the targeted transmission rates and power allocation factors of NOMA users; and ii) For the case
that the interference power is proportional to the UAV power, there are error floors for the outage
probabilities.
Index Terms
MIMO, non-orthogonal multiple access, signal alignment, stochastic geometry, unmanned aerial
vehicles.
This work is supported by the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities under Grant 2016RC055. This paper
was presented at the IEEE Global Communication Conference, Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates, Dec. 2018 [1].
T. Hou, Z. Song and X. Sun are with the School of Electronic and Information Engineering, Beijing Jiaotong University,
Beijing 100044, China (email: 16111019@bjtu.edu.cn, songzy@bjtu.edu.cn, xsun@bjtu.edu.cn).
Y. Liu and Yue Chen are with School of Electronic Engineering and Computer Science, Queen Mary University of London,
London E1 4NS, U.K. (e-mail: yuanwei.liu@qmul.ac.uk, yue.chen@qmul.ac.uk).
8
1
0
2
y
a
M
4
1
]
T
I
.
s
c
[
1
v
5
8
9
4
0
.
5
0
8
1
:
v
i
X
r
a
2
I. INTRODUCTION
In the fifth generation (5G) communication systems and internet of things (IoT) networks,
massive connectivity is required to support large number of devices in various scenarios with
limited spectrum resources [2], [3]. Unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) communication is an
effective approach to provide connectivity during temporary events and after disasters. Some
initial research contributions in the field of UAVs communication have been made by researchers
in [4]–[8]. UAVs can provide connectivity to multiple users as wireless relays for improving
wireless coverage. On the other hand, ground users can have access to UAVs, which can act as
aerial base stations, for reliable downlink and uplink communications [4]–[6]. Additionally, UAV
networks are capable of enhancing spectrum efficiency by having line-of-sight (LoS) connections
towards the users, which provide higher received power for the users [7], [8].
Non-orthogonal multiple access (NOMA) has been considered as a promising technique in
5G mobile networks because of its superior spectrum efficiency [9], [10]. The key idea is that
multiple users are served within the same frequency, time and code block [11], [12], which relies
on the employment of superposition coding (SC) and successive interference cancellation (SIC)
at the transmitter and receiver, respectively [13]. Moreover, SIC technique at receivers allows
that users who have better channel conditions to remove the intra-channel interference. Ding
et al. [14] estimated the performance of NOMA with fixed power allocation (F-NOMA) and
cognitive radio inspired NOMA, which demonstrated that only the user with higher channel gain
influences the system performance. Timotheou and Krikidis optimized the user-power allocation
problem to improve user fairness of a NOMA system [15]. To further exploit NOMA networks,
the outage performance and capacity in the downlink and uplink transmission scenario with
dynamic power allocation factors was estimated by Yang et al. [16], which can guarantee the
quality of service in dynamic power allocation NOMA (D-NOMA).
A. Motivations and Related Works
1) Studies on MIMO-NOMA systems: Current multiple-input multiple-output (MIMO) NOMA
applications can be primarily classified into a pair of categories, namely, beamformer based
structure and cluster based structure. In beamformer based structure, one centralized beamformer
serves only one user in a beam [17]. Choi proposed a coordinated multi-point transmission
scheme in [18], where two base stations (BS) serve paired NOMA users simultaneously by
3
beamformer based structure. The multiple antenna scenario of beamformer based structure was
proposed by Shin et al. in [19], where a joint centralized and coordinated beamforming de-
sign was developed for suppressing the inter-cell interference. Some related works on cluster
based MIMO-NOMA have been investigated in [20]–[22], [22], [23]. More specifically, Ding et
al. [20] proposed a MIMO-NOMA model with transmit power control and detection scheme. By
adopting this design, the MIMO-NOMA model can be separated to multiple independent SISO-
NOMA arrangements. Then, outage probabilities and the sum rate gap of multiple SISO-NOMA
arrangements were estimated, which the model assumes that global channel state information
(CSI) is unknown at the BS. The sum rate and multi-user capacity were investigated by Zeng et
al. [24], which show that multi-user MIMO-NOMA is not a preferable solution of NOMA due
to high computational complexity. In order to establish a more general framework of MIMO-
NOMA, and circumvent the restrictive assumption of receiver antennas, the signal alignment
technique was proposed for both downlink and uplink transmission scenarios in [21].
2) Studies on NOMA in stochastic geometry systems: Stochastic geometry is an effective
mathematical tool for capturing the topological randomness of networks. As such, stochastic
geometry tools were invoked to model the impact of the locations for NOMA users [25]. Some
research contributions with utilizing stochastic geometry approaches have been studied in [22],
[23]. More particularly, Liu et al. [22] proposed an innovative model of cooperative NOMA with
simultaneous wireless information and power transfer (SWIPT). In this model, the wireless power
transfer technique was employed at users, where near users acted as energy harvesting relays
for supporting far users. Ding et al. [25] evaluated the performance of NOMA with randomly
deployed users. The analytical results show that it is more preferable to group users whose
channel gains are more distinctive to improve the diversity order in NOMA system. With the goal
of enhancing the physical layer security of NOMA networks, Liu et al. [23] proposed a NOMA
assisted physical layer security framework in large-scale networks. The secrecy performance of
both single antenna and multiple antenna aided BS scenarios have been investigated.
3) Studies on UAV: In UAV aided wireless networks, the probability that each device has a
LoS link is dependent on the environment, location of the device, carrier frequency and the
elevation angle [4], [8], [26]. Sharma and Kim estimated the outage performance of single
antenna assisted NOMA in UAV networks [27], where UAV-ground channels are characterized
by LoS transmission. Recently, the general form of both LoS and NLoS transmission scenarios,
4
namely, Nakagami-m fading channels, have been proposed in the literature. Hou et al. [28]
estimated the outage performance of F-NOMA downlink transmission scenario in both LoS and
NLoS scenarios.
While the aforementioned research contributions have laid a solid foundation with providing
a good understanding of single input single output (SISO) NOMA terrestrial networks, how
MIMO-NOMA technique is capable of assisting UAV networks is still unknown. To the best
of our knowledge, there has been no existing work intelligently investigating the effect of the
network performance of MIMO-NOMA assisted UAV networks, which motivates us to develop
this treatise.
B. Contributions
The novel structure design in this work–by introducing the MIMO-NOMA assisted UAV
networks–can be a new highly rewarding candidate, which will contribute the following key
advantages:
• We propose a general MIMO-NOMA aided UAV framework with interference, where
stochastic geometry approaches are invoked to model the locations of users and interference
sources. Utilizing this framework, LoS and NLoS links are considered to illustrate the
general case of NOMA assisted UAV networks.
• We derive closed-form expressions for outage probability of paired NOMA users in the
proposed framework. We provide tractable analytical upper bounds for both LoS and NLoS
scenarios. Diversity orders are obtained for the paired NOMA users based on the developed
outage probability. The obtained results confirm that for the case that interference power is
proportional to the transmit power, diversity orders of paired NOMA users are zero.
• We derive exact analytical expressions for ergodic rate in both LoS and NLoS scenarios. We
provide tractable analytical lower bounds for the general case. We also provide closed-form
expressions for the special case when the path loss is three. We obtain high SNR slopes for
the paired NOMA users based on the developed ergodic rate. The obtained results confirm
that the high SNR slopes of far users are zero in both LoS and NLoS scenarios.
• We demonstrate that 1) the outage performance and ergodic rate can be enhanced by the
LoS propagation; 2) the ergodic rates of near users have the same rate ceiling in both LoS
and NLoS scenarios; 3) diversity orders and high SNR slopes of paired NOMA users are
5
not affected by the LoS transmission of the proposed framework.
C. Organization and Notations
The rest of the paper is organized as follows. In Section II, a model of UAV-aided transmission
scenario is investigated in wireless networks, where NOMA users are uniformly allocated on the
ground. Then precoding and detection strategies have proposed for UAV networks. Analytical
results are presented in Section III to show the performance of UAV-aided MIMO-NOMA
networks. Our numerical results are demonstrated in Section IV for verifying our analysis, which
is followed by the conclusion in Section V. Table I lists all notations used in this article.
TABLE I: TABLE OF NOTATIONS
k and α2
α2
k
Pu
PI
tk and tk
α
Rm and Rd
Rk and Rk
m
Power allocation factors
Transmit power of the UAV
Transmit power of interference sources
Detection vectors
Path loss exponent
The radius of small disc and large disc
The target rate of the k-th user and of the k-th user
Small-scale fading parameter
II. MIMO-NOMA ASSISTED UAV NETWORK MODEL
Consider a MIMO-NOMA downlink communication scenario in which a UAV equipped with
K antennas is communicating with multiple users equipped with N antennas each. Fig. 1
illustrates the wireless communication model with a single UAV, which is supported by MIMO
beamforming, namely the cluster-based MIMO-NOMA. Multiple users are grouped into one
cluster, and the UAV serves multiple clusters simultaneously in the cluster-based MIMO-NOMA,
which can perfectly improve the system performance [17], [29].
A. System Description
The UAV cell coverage is a disc area, denoted by D, which has a coverage radius of Rd.
It is assumed that the users are uniformly distributed according to HPPPs distribution, which
is denoted by Ψ and associated with the density λ, within large disc D and small disc with
radius Rd and Rm, respectively. For simplicity, we only focus our attention on investigating a
6
Fig. 1: Illustration of a typical UAV cellular network supported by beamforming.
typical user pairing in this treatise, where two users are grouped to deploy NOMA transmission
protocol.
The downlink users also detect signals sent by interferers which are distributed in R according
to HPPPs distribution ΨI with density λI [30]. It is assumed that the interference sources are
equipped with one antenna each and use identical transmission power, which is denoted by PI.
B. Channel Model
Consider the use of a composite channel model with two parts, large-scale fading and small-
scale fading. gk,kn denotes the channel coefficient between the k-th antenna of the UAV and the
n-th antenna of the k-th user, and the channel gain gk,kn is modelled as
gk,kn = βk,knhk,kn,
(1)
where βk,kn and hk,kn denotes the large-scale fading and small-scale fading, respectively. It is
assumed that βk,kn and hk,kn with k = 1, ...K, n = 1, ..., N, are independent and identically
distributed (i.i.d.). In this paper, large-scale fading represents the path loss and shadowing
between the UAV and users. Generally speaking, the large-scale fading between the k-th user
zxhOriginRmRdBeamformingdirections
and the UAV changes slightly for different antenna pairs, which can be expressed as
βk = βk,kn,∀k = 1··· K, n = 1··· N.
For simplicity, the small-scale fading matrix from the UAV to user k is defined as
Hk =
,
hk,11
...
··· hk,K1
...
...
hk,1N ··· hk,KN
where Hk is a N × K matrix whose elements represent Nakagami-m fading channel gains. The
density function of the elements is f (x) = mmxm−1
Γ(m) e−mx, where m denotes the fading parameter.
In this paper, the UAV can be projected to the coverage disc by projection theorem. Thus, the
distance between the UAV to user k can be written as
where h denotes the height of the UAV, and rk is the horizontal distance between the k-th user
and projective point of the UAV. Therefore, the large-scale fading can be expressed as
7
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
dk =
h2 + r2
k,
βk =
d−α
k ,
where α denotes the path loss exponent. For simplicity, we still use βk to represent the large-
scale fading between the UAV and the k-th user in Section II. Thus, the received power for the
k-th user from the UAV is given by
Pk = Puβk|Hk|2,
(6)
where Pu denotes the transmit power of the UAV. Besides, it is assumed that the CSI of users
is perfectly known at the UAV. The proposed MIMO-NOMA assisted UAV network model for
downlink transmission is described in the following subsection.
C. Downlink transmission
In this subsection, we estimate the downlink quality of MIMO-NOMA assisted single UAV
networks, where two users, i.e., the k-th user and the k-th user, are grouped to perform NOMA.
We consider a more practicable method that the number of antenna equipped on each user is
assumed to greater than 0.5K, i.e., N ≥ 0.5K. In the beginning, it is assumed that the maximum
clusters is K. Therefore, the UAV sends the following K × 1 information-bearing vector s to
users as follows:
s =
,
(7)
where sk is the signal intended for the k-th user, αk is the power allocation coefficient, and
α2
k + α2
k = 1. The co-channel interference Ik can be further expressed as follows:
8
(8)
(9)
α1s1 + α1s1
...
αksk + αksk
...
αKsK + αKsK
j∈ΨI
∆=
Ik
PId−α
j,k 1N×1,
where 1k×n denotes an k×n all one matrix, dj,k denotes the distance from the k-th user to the j-
th interference source. ΨI and PI are the HPPPs distribution and the single antenna transmission
power of interference sources, respectively. The interference model omits the small scale fading,
since the effect of path loss is the dominant part for the long distance interferences.
Similar to [21], [31], the detection vectors t can be designed as follows:
= Dkxk,
tk
tk
where xk denotes a (2N − K) × 1 vector, which is normalized to 2, i.e., |xk|2 = 2. Dk denotes
a 2N × (2N − K) matrix containing the (2N − K) right singular vectors of
corresponding to its zero singular values.
k −HH
HH
k
∆= HH
Define bk
··· bK
k tk as the effective channel vector shared by users in the cluster, B ∆=
, and (·)k,k denotes the k-th element on the main diagonal of the matrix.
Thus, with the design of precoding matrix P and detection vector t in [21], [31], the signal-to-
b1
H